Reviewed · ST AUGUSTINE
CraigCat Boat Tour from Fernandina Beach
Cumberland Island’s wild horses are the star here, but the unusual part is how you reach them: you drive your own two-seat CraigCat in a small guided group. The route passes historic Fernandina Beach, heads through Amelia Island’s waterways, and reaches Georgia’s Cumberland Island, where you may see horses, dolphins, birds, alligators, and even sharks’ teeth on the shore.
I like the mix of hands-on boating and local history, and I like that the tour stays small, with no more than eight people. Guides such as Kyle, Zack, Bill, Nathan, and Brandon have been praised for clear instructions and local stories. The main drawback is comfort: you should expect spray, and rough wind or boat wakes can make the ride a hard bounce.
Key points at a glance

- Drive your own CraigCat: You operate a two-seat boat while following your guide.
- Reach Cumberland Island by water: The route offers a fresh view of Amelia Island and Fernandina Beach.
- Wildlife is part of the fun: Look for dolphins, wild horses, birds, alligators, pelicans, and possibly sea turtles.
- Expect a wet ride: Bring sunscreen, beach shoes, and clothes that can handle spray.
- Small-group format: The tour has a maximum of eight people and lasts about two and a half hours.
- Good value for active visitors: At $145 per person, you pay for a guided boat excursion, wildlife viewing, history, and time ashore.
Why the CraigCat makes this tour different

Many boat trips leave you sitting still while someone else handles the controls. This one gives you a more active role. After the safety briefing and basic instruction, you pilot your own CraigCat while staying with the guide and the other boats.
The CraigCat is a compact, two-seat boat that feels easy to handle for first-time operators. You are not expected to navigate the waterways alone. The guide leads the group, sets the pace, points out sights, and helps you feel comfortable at the controls.
That arrangement works especially well for couples. One person drives while the other watches for dolphins, takes photos, or enjoys the view, then you can switch roles if appropriate. Families and groups can also enjoy it, though the two-seat setup means you should plan who will ride together.
The boats are fun because you feel close to the water. That also means you feel the chop. Several outings have been described as smooth and enjoyable, while wind and wakes made other rides bouncy. The practical rule is simple: slow down for large wakes and expect to get splashed.
More Boat Tours in St Augustine:
- Take a Scenic Boat Ride in St. Augustine
★ 4.5 · 1,399 reviews - Sunset Cruise of St. Augustine
★ 5.0 · 1,235 reviews - Chicago Architecture River Cruise
★ 5.0 · 15,756 reviews
Leaving Amelia Island Marina
The meeting point is Amelia Island Marina at 251 Creekside Drive in Fernandina Beach. The tour begins and ends there, so you do not need to arrange a separate ride from the water landing.
The first part of the trip takes you past historic Fernandina Beach. Your guide gives a short introduction to the island and the area’s past as you move along the water. This is not a long formal history talk. Instead, it gives the scenery some context while you get used to the boat.
I like this opening because it lets you settle into the experience before the wildlife search begins. You see the waterfront from a lower, more open angle than you would from a car or walking route. Guides including Zack and Kyle have been praised for making the local details easy to follow without turning the ride into a lecture.
The group size matters here. With a maximum of eight people, the guide can keep an eye on the boats and answer questions. It also keeps the trip from feeling like a large commercial cruise.
Crossing toward Cumberland Island

The route continues through the waterways around Amelia Island and toward Cumberland Island in Georgia. The scenery changes as the tour moves away from the developed waterfront and into quieter marsh and shoreline areas.
This is the part where you should keep your eyes moving. Dolphins may appear near the boat, and some outings have included pods feeding in the water. You may also spot pelicans, eagles, other birds, alligators, or sea turtles. Wildlife is never guaranteed, but the route gives you a good reason to watch the banks and open water rather than stare only at the captain’s boat.
You might also see working waterfront activity, shipyards, large boats, and pleasure craft along the way. That mix gives the ride more variety than a simple out-and-back cruise. One moment you are passing signs of local industry, and the next you are scanning a marsh edge for movement.
The guide plays an important role in this section. Kyle has been praised for combining useful information with a relaxed manner, while Zack has been noted for helping people feel comfortable with the boat. Nathan and Brandon have also been singled out for being friendly and patient. The quality of the guide matters because the wildlife can be easy to miss without someone who knows where to look.
Cumberland Island, horses, ruins, and shore time

The main stop is Cumberland Island, where the tour combines wildlife with a short break on or near the shore. The island is known for its wild horses, and seeing one grazing near the beach can be the highlight of the outing.
The horse sightings vary. Some trips have seen one horse, while others have seen a dozen or more. You should treat the horses as wild animals and watch them from a respectful distance. The appeal is that you are seeing them in their natural setting, not at a managed attraction.
The island also offers room to walk around and look for shells. Several outings have found sharks’ teeth, unusual shells, or other small shoreline discoveries. Bring a small bag if you want to collect permitted finds, but keep your attention on the surroundings rather than turning the stop into a frantic treasure hunt.
The tour also includes Cumberland Island’s historic side. You may see the Dungeness Ruins area and a 19th-century fort, with the guide providing background about the places you pass. The ruins are a useful contrast to the wild shoreline. They remind you that this peaceful stretch of coast has a long human story as well as a strong natural presence.
Do not expect a full island tour on foot. The total activity lasts about two hours and 30 minutes, so the Cumberland Island stop is one part of a larger boat route. You get enough time to step ashore, look around, and search for wildlife, but this is not a substitute for spending a full day exploring the island.
A few more St Augustine days worth weighing up
- St. Augustine Hop-On Hop-Off Trolley Tour
★ 4.5 · 3,799 reviews - St. Augustine Ghost Tour: A Ghostly Encounter
★ 4.5 · 2,404 reviews - Medieval Torture Museum with Ghost Hunting and Tiny Art Gallery
★ 5.0 · 2,011 reviews - St. Augustine’s Wine, Cocktail and Food Experience
★ 5.0 · 1,251 reviews
Wildlife watching without false promises
This is a wildlife trip, but nature does not follow a schedule. Dolphins, birds, alligators, and horses have all been seen, sometimes on the same outing. Other trips may produce fewer sightings.
I would book this for the water experience first and treat the animals as a bonus. That is the safest way to judge the value. The boat ride, island stop, and local stories still give you a worthwhile outing if the dolphins stay away or the horses are out of sight.
Dolphins can be especially exciting because they may surface close to the boats. You might see a single animal or several together. Bird sightings can include pelicans and eagles, and alligators may appear in the marshy areas. You should keep your camera ready, but do not let the search spoil the ride.
The horses are often the most memorable sight because they make Cumberland Island feel different from a standard beach stop. Seeing them near the grass or shoreline gives the visit a sense of place that a regular boat rental cannot match.
Weather, spray, and the ride itself
You will probably get wet. Spray can reach the boat, and wind can turn a calm ride into a rough one. One particularly useful tip is to slow down when crossing large wakes. The CraigCat can be a kidney-rattling ride if you hit chop at speed.
Check the forecast before booking, especially if you prefer a smooth outing. A calm, sunny day will make it easier to enjoy the scenery, operate the boat, and take photographs. Windy conditions may still produce a fun adventure, but you should arrive ready for more bouncing and spray.
Pack sunscreen. The Florida sun can feel strong even when the air is comfortable, and you are exposed on the water for much of the trip. Wear water shoes or other beach-friendly footwear, since your feet may get wet and you may walk on the island shore.
A waterproof box is available for electronics, which is useful, but do not treat it as permission to handle your phone carelessly around the water. If you take the phone out for pictures, secure it before moving around. A towel and a small waterproof bag are sensible additions.
Is $145 per person fair?
The price is $145 per person. That is not a bargain-basement boat ride, but it includes more than simply sitting in a vessel for two hours. You get the CraigCat, a guide, instruction, a small-group format, the route toward Cumberland Island, time near the island, and the chance to see wildlife and historic sites.
The strongest value comes from the hands-on element. You are not just paying for transportation. You are paying to operate a distinctive boat while someone else handles the route and points out the area.
The price makes the most sense for couples, families, and small groups who want an active outing rather than a passive cruise. If you only want a short dolphin-viewing trip, a less expensive option might suit you better. If you want boating, scenery, local information, a shoreline stop, and a chance to see wild horses, the cost is easier to justify.
The tour is often booked about 10 days ahead, so I would not leave it until the last minute during a busy Amelia Island visit. The ticket is mobile, the tour is offered in English, and confirmation is issued at booking.
One firm caution: the booking is non-refundable and cannot be changed for any reason. Check your schedule and the weather outlook carefully before paying.
Who will enjoy this most

I would recommend this tour to people who like being outdoors and do not mind getting splashed. Couples get a lively way to explore the coast, and families can share the excitement of steering their own boats and watching for wildlife.
It can also suit a mixed-age group. Outings have included families ranging from teenagers to older adults, with everyone enjoying the boats and island stop. Still, the ride is active and can be rough in wind, so comfort with water and motion matters.
This may not be the best choice if you want a quiet, polished cruise, guaranteed animal sightings, or lots of time walking Cumberland Island. It is also worth thinking carefully about the two-seat arrangement if you are bringing a larger family. The tour can include several boats, but each CraigCat seats two.
The guide’s support makes the experience approachable for first-time boat operators. Kyle, Zack, Bill, Nathan, and Brandon have each been praised for clear direction, patience, safety reminders, and local stories. That human guidance is a major part of what you are buying.
Should you book the CraigCat tour?
Book it if you want a hands-on coastal adventure with a real chance of seeing dolphins, wild horses, birds, and alligators. The combination of driving your own boat, visiting Cumberland Island, and hearing about Fernandina Beach gives you more variety than a standard water ride.
I would choose a calm, sunny day, wear clothes and shoes that can get wet, and bring sunscreen, a towel, and secure protection for your phone. If rough water makes you uncomfortable, wait for a better forecast.
At $145 per person, this is best for someone who values an active experience and a small group. It is not the cheapest way to see the area, but it offers a memorable mix of boating, wildlife, history, and shoreline time in about two and a half hours.
FAQ
Where does the CraigCat boat tour begin?
The tour begins at Amelia Island Marina, 251 Creekside Drive, Fernandina Beach, Florida 32034.
Where does the tour end?
The activity ends back at Amelia Island Marina, the same place where it begins.
How long does the tour last?
The tour lasts approximately two hours and 30 minutes.
How much does the tour cost?
The listed price is $145 per person.
Do I drive the boat?
Yes. You drive your own two-seat CraigCat while following a guide during the tour.
How many people can join?
The tour has a maximum of eight travelers.
What wildlife might I see?
Possible sightings include dolphins, wild horses, birds, pelicans, eagles, alligators, and sea turtles. Sightings are not guaranteed.
Will I get wet?
You should expect to get splashed. Wind and rough water can make the ride wetter and more bouncy, so wear suitable clothing and shoes.
Is the tour refundable if I cancel?
No. The experience is non-refundable and cannot be changed for any reason after booking.
Just added around St Augustine
- Amelia Island Guided Kayak Tour of Lofton Creek★ 5.0 · 375 reviews
- St. Augustine: Ghosts and Gravestones Old Town Trolley Tour★ 4.4 · 370 reviews
- St Augustine: Nights of Lights Trolley Tour★ 4.3 · 1,061 reviews
- St. Augustine: Hop-on Hop-off Trolley Tour with Museum Entry★ 4.6 · 970 reviews
- Airboat Adventure in Saint Augustine with a Guide★ 5.0 · 902 reviews
- Haunted Trolley Tour of St Augustine★ 4.0 · 1,088 reviews
- Take a Scenic Boat Ride in St. Augustine★ 4.5 · 1,399 reviews
- St. Augustine’s Wine, Cocktail and Food Experience★ 5.0 · 1,251 reviews
St Augustine Tours, compared.

St. Augustine Ghost Tour: A Ghostly Encounter
Read our review →
Medieval Torture Museum with Ghost Hunting and Tiny Art Gallery
Read our review →
St. Augustine’s Wine, Cocktail and Food Experience
Read our review →
Dolphin, Manatee and SeaTurtle SUP Adventure Tour of St Augustine
Read our review →
Private Guided Historic Electric Cart Tour of St. Augustine
Read our review →Browse the lists this tour appears in



